BUFFALO NEWS REVIEW 4/5/09
'Waterboarding' tensely lives up to its name
THREE STARS!!!
By Colin Dabkowski BUFFALO NEWS ARTS WRITER
You could almost hear Rod Serling's deep voice speaking matter-of-factly
between puffs on his Chesterfield cigarette:
"In tonight's tall tale from the timberlands of the 'Twilight Zone,'
Kurt Schneiderman takes us deep into the heart of a war zone."
It's a pity the late "Twilight Zone" creator and narrator Serling
wasn't on hand at Subversive Theatre's premiere of "Waterboarding
Blues" at the Manny Fried Playhouse Friday night. But the
otherworldly one-act, an original piece by Subversive's founder and artistic
director Schneiderman, had Serling's irresistible and heavy-handed stamp all
over it.
Schneiderman's company, which moved into its very utilitarian theater in
the Great Arrow Building last September, has always produced theater whose
primary goal is to awaken its audience to global injustices. With "Waterboarding,"
Subversive turns its laser focus on the war in Iraq (or "the global war
on terror," or, lately, "the overseas contingency operation")
and infuses it with just the sort of stylized language and moralistic premise
that made the "Twlight Zone" such a cult favorite.
The play centers on a Marine intelligence officer, Gordon Tashjian as
Captain Sterling (the reference to Serling is not accidental), whose primary
duty is to extract information from prisoners of war using a litany of
post-9/11 tactics, including stress positions, sleep deprivation and
waterboarding -- which is widely defined as torture.
His commanding officer, Col. Carnovsky (who could be played a bit more
commandingly by Dennis Keefe), is a sort of Patton-esque blowhard who, along
with Sterling, is the subject of derision and scrutiny from the media after a
respected imam dies in Sterling's interrogation room under suspicious
circumstances.
Shortly after meeting Sterling and his subordinate Lt. Thorne (James Wild),
the weirdness begins. A man who speaks only Polish is dragged into the
interrogation room and later claims to be a member of the Polish resistance to
the Nazis during World War II. Sterling chalks it up to insanity or a
bizarre political stunt, but soon enough a humble carpenter dressed in Arabic
clothing is brought in. He speaks only Aramaic, pleads for the release
of his son, Jesus Christ, and mistakes Sterling for -- you guessed it --
Pontius Pilate.
Schneiderman's writing is smart, strong and, for the most part, deeply
affecting. A speech delivered by Keefe as the colonel is as devastating and
well-crafted a description of the imperialist ethos as I've heard.
But things start to go off in an irrevocably preachy direction even Serling
might have balked at during the play's overwritten climactic scene between
Sterling and the last of the bizarre prisoners, a soldier from the
Revolutionary War. It could use some paring down, as could scenes
involving the humanizing but largely superfluous character of Merissa (Jessica
Stuber), Sterling's daughter.
But with "Waterboarding Blues," Schneiderman puts us all
on notice: While we listened to inane reports about the definition of
waterboarding on NPR, some supposed enemy combatant halfway around the world
was lying on a wooden plank with his head wrapped in cellophane. No
matter how many times he stretches credulity with this play, Schneiderman
forces us to think about that image in deeply critical ways -- something
Serling would be proud of.
cdabkowski@buffnews.com
|